skip to Main Content skip to Section Navigation in text click here to go to site navigation in text
nms logo for banner graphic banner
click here to go to home pageclick here to go to site search
click here to go to the about the mbnms section click here to go to the visitors information section click here to go to the research and monitoring section click here to go to the resource management issues section click here to go to the education and research section
facebook twitter

Resource Protection Issues

Acoustic Impacts

Beach Closures

Coastal Armoring

Cruise Ships

Desalination

Dredging

Ecosystem-Based Management Initiative

Ecosystem Conservation & Biodiversity Protection

Emergency Response & Oil Spills

Fishing

Invasive Species

Kelp Harvesting

Krill Harvesting

Landslide Disposal

Lost Fishing Gear

Marine Protected Areas

Maritime Heritage

Military Activities

Motorized Personal

Watercraft

Oil & Gas Development

Seabed Disturbance

Vessel Traffic

Water Quality

Wildlife Disturbance

 
  Resource Protection Issues:
Lost Fishing Gear Project
 
LFG Report Pic 2010 Lost Fishing Gear Project Cruise Report
(820KB PDF*)

 

 

 

 

 

The Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary (MBNMS) and partners are implementing a multi-year project to remove lost fishing gear from the deepwater habitats of the sanctuary using a remotely operated vehicle (ROV). The primary goals of the Lost Fishing Gear Project are to:
  1. Reduce benthic and pelagic hazards to marine organisms posed by fishing debris lost in deepwater.
  2. Develop and test deepwater retrieval procedures.
  3. Reduce navigational hazards for fishermen and other boaters.
  4. Conduct site surveys and characterizations.
  5. Provide outreach through images and HD video.
  6. Provide technical experience for staff and partners.
Overview of the Issue
Lost fishing gear is identified as fishing nets, lines, pots, traps, and other commercial and recreational fishing gear that sits on the seafloor, gets caught on rocky reefs, or floats in the water column. The National Marine Fisheries Service and the MBNMS have documented lost fishing gear during Delta Submarine dives in 2003, 2004 and 2007. This gear includes long lines, gill nets, crab and fish traps, and trawling gear, which can become lodged or entangled on the seafloor and sometimes extending into the water column. Lost fishing gear is a concern for the following reasons:
Spot Prawn Trap
Spot prawn trap retrieved in Point Lobos State Marine Conservation area at 250 meters.
  • Gear can create long-term entrapment mechanisms that continuously impact fish and crustaceans for many years. Net materials are constructed to be strong and resilient, thus preventing escape of entangled wildlife and persisting in the environment for decades.
  • Nets and traps have also been documented to entangle bottom feeding whales and other marine mammals, becoming ensnared on flukes and fins.
  • Lost fishing gear can cause hazards to fishing gear being actively used by fishermen. For example, lost traps may snag additional traps being set nearby. Catching new gear on lost gear is a nuisance and a hazard.
Methods
The Lost Fishing Gear team has conducted two missions from the F/V Donna Kathleen during 2009 and 2010 to survey the deepwater habitats of MBNMS and test new methods to remove lost fishing gear from the seafloor. During this time, operations focused on the Monterey Bay proper region. A priority goal of these operations was to develop and refine methods for ROV retrieval of fishing gear from deepwater habitats between 100 – 300 meters. These depths are beyond traditional removal methods used in nearshore habitats such as recreational and technical SCUBA diving.
F/V Donna Kathleen
The fishing vessel Donna Kathleen makes an excellent platform for ROV and other marine research projects. Captain Tim Maricich and his son Tyler and wife Donna are an ideal crew for this particular project due to their knowledge and understanding of fishing gear as well as the local sites.
The MBNMS ROV removal methods were built upon prior work in Cordell Bank National Marine Sanctuary in 2008. The same sanctuary ROV was retooled for a diversity of deepwater habitats to locate, document and retrieve lost fishing gear off the Monterey Peninsula. Due to the accuracy of the target data collected by the MBNMS and National Marine Fisheries Service using the Delta Submarine, the Lost Fishing Gear team was able to achieve 95% success rate in finding targets and putting the ROV onto identified nets and traps, usually in less than 30 minutes.

After locating the targets, the ROV was launched from the F/V Donna Kathleen along with a clump weight from the crane, boom and winch. The vessel was set up to drift with the wind and current toward the general target area. The ROV was lifted by the crane and boom, lowered into the water, released from the winch line, and swum out 40 meters from the vessel prior to launching the 600-pound clump weight attached to the winch cable and lowered into the water a few meters. At this point, the ROV tether was secured to the clump weight winch line, and thereafter every 3 meters until the clump weight reached 5 to 10 meters from the bottom to prevent contact with the seafloor. Depending on visibility, the ROV operated at 0.5 to 2 meters from the seafloor at speeds ranging from .5 to 1.5 knots. The ROV proceeded along a determined transect or search pattern, but its course was altered depending on the bottom relief and presence of lost fishing gear. Observations of gear were recorded and potential targets of interest carefully documented.

ROV Retrieval
The ROV is retrieved using the power of the boat winch and is carefully landed on deck.

The following criteria were used to decide on removal of fishing gear: Impacts to animals and habitat with a high priority given to endangered or protected species and sensitive habitats; threats to fishing operations (increases risk for more gear to be snagged); impacts to habitat as a result of removal; and feasibility of removal.

One of two retrieval methods was employed:
  1. A snipping device attached to the manipulating arm cut the line and the grabbing device grasped the net fragment and pulled it up as the ROV was retrieved; and
  2. A carabineer (metal hook) was clipped onto the net or trap with the grabbing arm, and as the ROV was retrieved, the spool line paid out to the surface. The spool line was then transferred to the boat's hydraulic winch and the gear was hauled up to the surface. At the completion of the dive, the ROV began its ascent while the winch raised the clump weight. Once recovered, the crane boomed in to place the clump weight on the deck. It boomed back out for ROV recovery.
Results
During the 2009 cruise, the team focused efforts within a state marine protected area in an effort to enhance its productivity by reducing the potential for entanglement of living marine resources. The team completed 22 ROV dives over 8 days. The majority of the dives (15) were conducted over Portuguese Ledge SMCA at depths ranging from 75 to 100 meters. The remaining dives were conducted in Carmel Bay (3) and off Cypress Point (1) at depths ranging from 45 to 260 meters. The total amount of removed fishing gear weighed over 500 pounds, and included a crab pot, a boat anchor, two 100-foot gillnets and a 40-foot rockfish gillnet fragment. Over 70 monofilament targets were marked while conducting an ROV transect in Portuguese Ledge State Marine Conservation Area.

2010 LFG Project Map 2009 LFG Project Map
2010 Lost Fishing Gear Project Map
(352KB JPEG)
2009 Lost Fishing Gear Project Map
(295KB JPEG)

In 2010, the team completed 19 ROV dives over 10 days. Dives were conducted along the edges of Monterey Canyon, at the edge of Soquel Canyon and at Point Lobos. Roughly half were in state marine protected areas while the others were in currently fished areas. Adding locations outside the state marine protected areas provided the opportunity to retrieve newer gear which is more likely to continue to trap fish and invertebrates. The team retrieved 450 feet of rockfish gill net in 250-300 meters depth, two crab pots in 225 meters, a spot prawn trap in 275 meters and 600 pounds of lead weights in 100 meters. During HD video surveys, additional gear found included a large, intact trawl net and a 50-foot sunken sailboat. The large trawl net, complete with headline, steel cabled footline and both doors, weighing approximately 2,200 pounds and located in a state marine conservation area, has been identified as a priority target for removal operations in 2011.

Lophelia Pertusa
Lophelia Pertusa, a species of deepwater coral found encrusting a net in Monterey Bay is rarely seen in the Pacific Ocean.

Retrieved gear can be either lightly or heavily encrusted, yet most did not appear to be actively fishing. Specimen collection and photo documentation for the net encrusting invertebrates has also been a goal during this project. Documented species included brittle stars, urchins, tube worms, bristle worms, octopi, brachiopods, nudibranchs, glass sponges, nipple sponges, shrimp, squat lobsters decorator crabs, cat shark egg cases, chitons, cup corals, cookie cutter stars, sun stars, metridium anemone sp, crinoids, flatfish, rockfish, and more.

Next Steps
Priority areas for retrieval operations in 2011 are sites in the Monterey Bay and the Point Sur region, and will include a combination of gear targets both inside and outside state marine protected areas, and include the large trawl net described above.

Collaborative Partners
The sanctuary funds this collaborative project within the MBNMS through a federal settlement that focuses on mitigating impacts to benthic habitats, and through a marine debris grant awarded to the UC Davis SeaDoc Society by the California Wildlife Conservation Board. Other key contributors to this effort include the California Department of Fish and Game, California State University Monterey Bay, Cordell Bank National Marine Sanctuary, the F/V Donna Kathleen, Marine Applied Research and Exploration, Monterey Peninsula College's MATE program, the National Marine Fisheries Service, and San Francisco State University's Romberg Tiburon Center.

On Facebook
For more information on this project contact: karen.grimmer@noaa.gov.


A brief introduction of the Deepwater Lost Fishing Gear Recovery project led by MBNMS. Here we showcase some specialized GIS tools that were used to analyze the density of the lost fishing gear that we found using an ROV.


A rockfish gill net is removed from 300 meters depth in Soquel Canyon SMCA using an ROV, a boat winch, and good, old fashioned elbow grease!

   
National Marine Sanctuaries | National Ocean Service | National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
U.S. Department of Commerce | NOAA Library

click here to go to the NOAA home page For Website comments/questions, contact the MBNMS Webmaster.
For programmatic comments/question, contact the appropriate MBNMS Staff
MBNMS Privacy Statement | Web Site Disclaimer | Web Site Owner: National Ocean Service
This page last modified on: 02/13/12
click here to go to the national marine sanctuaries home page

URL: http://montereybay.noaa.gov/resourcepro/resmanissues/lostgear.html